Skip to main content Subscribe TRENDING Physics & Astrophysics Roe v. Wade COVID-19 Fitness Pregnancy tips Live Science is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s why you can trust us Your Brain Is a Mosaic of Male and Female By Stephanie Pappas published December 01, 2015 (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (Image credit: Johan Swanepoel) There is no such thing as a « male brain » or a « female brain, » new research finds. Advertisement Instead, men and women’s brains are an unpredictable mishmash of malelike and femalelike features, the study concludes. Even in brain regions previously thought to show differences based on sex, variability is more common than consistency. « Our study demonstrates that although there are sex/gender differences in brain structure, brains do not fall into two classes, one typical of males and the other typical of females, nor are they aligned along a ‘male brain–female brain’ continuum, » the study researchers wrote today (Nov. 30) in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. « Rather, even when considering only the small group of brain features that show the largest sex/gender differences, each brain is a unique mosaic of features, some of which may be more common in females compared with males, others may be more common in males compared with females, and still others may be common in both females and males. » [10 Surprising Facts About a Woman’s Brain] Sponsored Links Create Your Offshore Business From Morocco Offshore | Search Ads Pink and blue brains? RECOMMENDED VIDEOS FOR YOU… 0 seconds of 10 minutes, 4 seconds  PLAY SOUND The new research is the first to examine sex differences in the brain as a whole. If the brain is truly sexually dimorphic, coming in a male and a female form, it should be consistently different between the two sexes, Tel Aviv University psychobiologist Daphna Joel and her colleagues wrote. Consider the peacock, with its sexually dimorphic tail: The difference in color and size is consistent between the sexes – there’s no subset of peahens brandishing iridescent purple feathers. Advertisement Clearly, brains don’t fit this pattern; there is far more variation in brains within sexes than between them, a fact that has been known for a long time, said Rebecca Jordan-Young, a professor of women’s gender & sexuality studies at Barnard College in New York and author of « Brain Storm: The flaws in the science of sex differences » (Harvard University Press, 2010). Many neuroscientists had already concluded that brains are checkered with a mix of male- and femalelike structures, said Jordan-Young, who was not involved in the new study. But despite this variation, there could still be a continuum of male-type and female-type brains, Joel and her colleagues reasoned, so long as the gender differences between structures are consistent between men and women. They decided to put the question to a test. The researchers combed through more than 1,400 magnetic resonance images (MRI) from multiple studies of male and female brains, focusing on regions with the largest gender differences. In the first analysis, using brain scans from 169 men and 112 women, the researchers defined « malelike » and « femalelike » as the 33 percent most extreme gender-difference scores on gray matter from 10 regions. Even with this generous designation of « male » and « female » scores, the researchers found little evidence of the consistency they would need to prove brain dimorphism. Only 6 percent of brains were internally consistent as male or female, meaning all 10 regions were either femalelike or malelike, the researchers found. Another analysis of more than 600 brains from 18- to 26-year-olds found that only 2.4 percent were internally consistent as male or female, while substantial variability was the rule for more than half (52 percent). In other words, there were very few individuals whose brain regions were all malelike or femalelike. And there was no clear continuum between the two endpoints. Instead, across both gray and white matter and in connectivity patterns, brains are so overlapping that calling a particular form male or female is meaningless, Joel and her colleagues wrote. [Men vs. Women: Our Key Physical Differences Explained] « Our results demonstrate that even when analyses are restricted to a small number of brain regions (or connections) showing the largest sex/gender differences, internal consistency is rare and is much less common than substantial variability (i.e., being at the one end of the ‘maleness-femaleness’ continuum on some elements and at the other end on other elements), » they wrote. A sexual mosaic « Anyone who is aware of current data on brain sex differences appreciates that there is no such thing as a monolithic ‘male brain’ or ‘female brain,’ in much the same way as there is no such thing as a male heart and a female heart, » said Lise Eliot, a neuroscientist at Rosalind Franklin University in Chicago and author of « Pink Brain, Blue Brain: How Small Differences Grow Into Troublesome Gaps — And What We Can Do About It » (Mariner, 2010). Eliot, who was not involved in the new study, said the research was an « innovative approach » to sifting through brain gender differences. While statistical differences between the genders exist, she told Live Science, the new study shows that the distribution of malelike and femalelike attributes is patchy, not uniform. Indeed, previous studies have found large areas of overlap in the structure of male and female brain structures, even when population-level gender differences are found. « Every individual could have part of both men and women in them, » radiologist Ragini Verma told Live Science in 2013 after finding differences in connectivity between male and female brains. The findings are consistent with an emerging line of research on the hormonal control of brain development, Joel and her colleagues wrote. Early on, neuroscientists had viewed sex-specific hormones as the key to sex difference in the brain, with testosterone « masculinizing » the brain and estrogen « feminizing » it. Though hormonal influences are important, the real story is far more complex, according to a 2011 review in Nature Neuroscience. A growing body of evidence suggests that development is a give-and-take between genetic, environmental and epigenetic (above the genome) factors, all of which are acting in parallel and influencing one another in complicated ways. Different brain regions react in different ways to sex-specific influences, which are not limited to estrogen and testosterone, that review found. Meanwhile, environmental influences such as prenatal or early-life stress can feed back into this process, again altering how the brain develops. All of these parallel processes could explain why simple stereotypes about male and female interests, abilities and intelligence so often fail on an individual level, Jordan-Young told Live Science. « The idea of a unified ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’ personality turns out not to describe real people, » she said. « It describes stereotypes to which we constantly compare ourselves and each other, but more people are ‘gender non-conforming’ than we generally realize. » Follow Stephanie Pappas on Twitter and Google+. Follow us @livescience, Facebook & Google+. Original article on Live Science. Stephanie Pappas (opens in new tab) Live Science Contributor Stephanie Pappas is a contributing writer for Live Science, covering topics ranging from geoscience to archaeology to the human brain and behavior. She was previously a senior writer for Live Science but is now a freelancer based in Denver, Colorado, and regularly contributes to Scientific American and The Monitor, the monthly magazine of the American Psychological Association. Stephanie received a bachelor’s degree in psychology from the University of South Carolina and a graduate certificate in science communication from the University of California, Santa Cruz.  MORE ABOUT… Which British monarch has reigned the longest? (What about the shortest?) LATEST Which is colder: The North or South Pole? SEE MORE LATEST Thick, black ‘hairs’ coated a man’s tongue. Here’s why. A man went to a dermatology clinic after the top of his tongue became coated in a dense carpet of hairlike fibers. His doctors quickly diagnosed him with a surprisingly common medical condition: « black hairy tongue, » known medically as lingua villosa nigra. Livescience Create Your Offshore Business From Morocco Offshore | Search Ads | Sponsored The Most Addictive Series Since 50 Shades of Grey Galatea App – Romance Stories | Sponsored Stop Eating Sunflower Seeds Right Now! It’s Dangerous! InspireDot | Sponsored Online Jobs in USA from Morocco. Salaries Will Surprise You Online Jobs In USA | Search Ads | Sponsored 2 monster black holes are headed toward a collision that will rock the fabric of space-time The two black holes will merge about 10,000 years from now and ripple the fabric of space-time in the process. Livescience Getting a Tech Job in the US Without a Degree May Be Easier Than You Think Tech Jobs in US | Search Ads | Sponsored Scientists discovered a new type of thermonuclear explosion that may never be seen again Astronomers may have discovered a new type of thermonuclear explosion that only occurs in neutron stars every 1,000 years. They call it a hyperburst. Livescience The cost of Luxury Villas in Dubai might surprise you Buy Villas in Dubai | Sponsored What countries and cities will disappear due to rising sea levels? What cities, states and countries are most at risk from rising sea levels? What can they do to protect themselves? Livescience Work as a truck driver in Canada (visa sponsorships might be available) Trucking Jobs | Sponsored First-ever scan of a dying human brain reveals life may actually ‘flash before your eyes’ A new case report of a man dying from a sudden heart attack while having an electroencephalogram has given scientists the first scan of a dying human brain. Livescience Pole Vaulter Gave Fans A Little Too Much Tip Parents | Sponsored Vikings’ ‘blood eagle’ torture was horrific — and may have actually happened An ancient torture method ascribed to the Vikings literally turned victims inside out. Known as the « blood eagle, » it would have been challenging to execute but wasn’t physically impossible, new research suggests. Livescience At 66, Costner Says ‘She Was The Love Of My Life’ Crowdy Fan | Sponsored Are daddy longlegs really the most venomous spiders in the world? Is there any truth to the tale that daddy longlegs are the most venomous spiders? Livescience Don’t Dress Yourself Old These- 17 Fashion Items Make You Look Older Habit Tribe | Sponsored World’s oldest mummy found in Portugal Previously undeveloped revealed 8,000-year-old signs of mummification — the earliest evidence found anywhere in the world. Livescience Get Donations from USA for Your Business in Casablanca Fast Accessible Financing To Small Businesses Donations | Search Ads | Sponsored What’s the longest-burning fire in the world? The oldest known burning fire in the world was likely ignited by lightning at least 5,500 years ago in Australia. Livescience Cyber Security Courses May Get You A Job Sooner Than You Think! Cyber Security Courses | Search Ads | Sponsored Octopuses torture and eat themselves after mating. Science finally knows why. Octopus mothers slam themselves against rocks and eat their own arms before their eggs hatch. Scientists have discovered what leads to the self-destruction. Livescience Who Are You? Your Fingers Will Tell The Truth! InspireDot | Sponsored Our universe may have a twin that runs backward in time A mirror universe that runs backward in time sprouted up before the Big Bang. Livescience House in Dubai Might Be Cheaper Than You Think! Search Here Dubai Houses | Sponsored Watch a python swallow an impala whole in this jaw-dropping video Livescience Scientists watched a star explode in real time for the first time ever Livescience Online Job in USA from Morocco. Salaries Might Surprise You! Online Jobs 2022 | Sponsored World’s first computer, the Antikythera Mechanism, ‘started up’ in 178 B.C., scientists claim The mysterious Antikythera mechanism, thought by some to be the world’s first computer, was first « started up » on Dec. 22, 178 B.C., archaeologists have now found. Livescience Man dies from caffeine overdose after drinking equivalent of 200 cups of coffee The man made an error when measuring caffeine powder that resulted in him consuming a fatal dose of caffeine. Livescience What’s the tallest wave ever recorded on Earth? In 1958, an earthquake in Alaska triggered the largest wave ever recorded on Earth, which reached a maximum height greater than the Empire State Building. Livescience MOST POPULAR Melatonin poisonings on the rise in US kids By Nicoletta Lanese2 days ago Oldest shoe in Norway, dating to 3,000 years ago, recovered from melting ice patch By Brandon Specktor2 days ago Watch the biggest-ever comet outburst spray dust across the cosmos By Stephanie Pappas2 days ago 2,100-year-old burial of woman lying on bronze ‘mermaid bed’ unearthed in Greece By Owen Jarus2 days ago The aliens are all hanging out on Dyson spheres circling white dwarfs, physicist argues By Paul Sutter2 days ago Great white sharks may have driven megalodon to extinction By Cameron Duke2 days ago Male spiders drum out mesmerizing syncopated beats to woo mates By Stephanie Pappas3 days ago Short-necked giraffe relative discovered in China. It used its helmet head to bash rivals. By Nicoletta Lanese3 days ago How this trippy illusion will make you see an ‘expanding black hole’ By Harry Baker3 days ago Texas woman gives birth to rare set of twins conceived one week apart. How is this possible? By Nicoletta Lanese3 days ago LIVE SCIENCE NEWSLETTER Stay up to date on the latest science news by signing up for our Essentials newsletter. Contact me with news and offers from other Future brands Receive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors SIGN ME UP By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions(opens in new tab) and Privacy Policy(opens in new tab) and are aged 16 or over. MOST READ MOST SHARED 1 Lasers reveal ‘lost’ pre-Hispanic civilization deep in the Amazon 2 What are the benefits of squats? 3 Warp drive experiment to turn atoms invisible could finally test Stephen Hawking’s most famous prediction 4 Coconut milk: nutrition facts and health benefits 5 Chinese scientists call for plan to destroy Elon Musk’s Starlink satellites HOW IT WORKS MAGAZINE (opens in new tab) ● (opens in new tab) The ultimate action-packed science and technology magazine bursting with exciting information about the universe From $3.99 (opens in new tab) VIEW(OPENS IN NEW TAB) Live Science is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site(opens in new tab). About Us(opens in new tab) Terms and conditions(opens in new tab) Privacy policy(opens in new tab) Cookies policy(opens in new tab) Accessibility Statement(opens in new tab) Topics(opens in new tab) Advertise with us(opens in new tab) Web notifications(opens in new tab) Careers(opens in new tab) © Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036. Unmute

Créez votre site Web avec WordPress.com
Commencer
%d blogueurs aiment cette page :
close-alt close collapse comment ellipsis expand gallery heart lock menu next pinned previous reply search share star